A series of consecutive federal emergency orders issued by the Trump administration has kept the Stanton Energy Center, a coal-fired power plant in Orlando, Florida, operating beyond its scheduled retirement date. According to an analysis by the Environmental Defense Fund, these interventions have cost Florida ratepayers approximately $25.6 million. The orders are part of a broader national effort that has preserved six coal plants from closure, resulting in total ratepayer costs estimated at $593 million across the United States.
A series of consecutive federal emergency orders issued by the Trump administration has kept the Stanton Energy Center, a coal-fired power plant in Orlando, Florida, operating beyond its scheduled retirement date. According to an analysis by the Environmental Defense Fund, these interventions have cost Florida ratepayers approximately $25.6 million. The orders are part of a broader national effort that has preserved six coal plants from closure, resulting in total ratepayer costs estimated at $593 million across the United States.
The Stanton Energy Center is one of six power-generating facilities nationwide where the administration ordered the reversal of plans to wind down coal operations. The Environmental Defense Fund reported that these orders were issued under a law designed for temporary emergencies, such as severe weather events, but have been repeatedly renewed by the Trump administration. In Florida, the Orlando Utilities Commission (OUC) had originally planned to move one of its two coal-fired plants at Stanton into a state of "extended cold shutdown" by the end of May 2026. This timeline was part of a broader strategy to transition to renewable energy sources and achieve net zero emissions by 2050.
The Department of Energy (DOE) issued an initial order to keep the plant running in June, followed by another in September that is set to expire on November 30. OUC serves as the state’s second-largest municipal utility, providing electricity to more than 288,000 customers across Orange and Osceola counties in central Florida.
Bradley Marshall, a senior attorney at Earthjustice, which filed a legal challenge against the Trump administration regarding the situation at Stanton, indicated that further extensions are likely. "If they stay true to form then they’re going to issue another order," Marshall said. He emphasized that the economic rationale for keeping the plant operational was absent. "We know that a lot of these coal plants were due to be retired for a reason. They simply weren’t economic to run anymore," he stated. "When you unexpectedly have to keep a plant running that you were planning to retire, and you don’t need to keep it running for any kind of reliability purpose but because the Trump administration has told you to keep it running, it shouldn’t be surprising there are a lot of economic costs associated with that."
The Department of Energy has justified the energy emergency in Florida by citing a shortage of facilities and anticipated growing demand linked to the state’s burgeoning data center industry. The agency also referenced a cold snap in February that strained OUC’s resources as contributing factors to the need for extended coal operations.
A DOE spokesperson defended the administration's actions against criticism from climate advocates. "Radical climate activists will say anything to further their anti-energy agenda," the spokesperson told Inside Climate News. "The Trump Administration’s actions—including saving six coal-fired plants, preserving more than 17 gigawatts of coal power from retirement, and unleashing backup power generation—likely saved hundreds of American lives during peak demand periods." The spokesperson added that the Energy Department remains committed to ensuring reliable power generation for American families and businesses, contrasting this approach with what they described as past "Democrat leaders’ energy subtraction policies" which they claimed threatened grid reliability.
However, the Environmental Defense Fund argued that the coal plant at Stanton, along with others under emergency orders, is not cost-competitive with clean energy sources. Financial reports from OUC indicate that coal has been its most expensive fuel per megawatt-hour in recent years. The group estimated that keeping the Stanton plant running costs approximately $6.2 million a month.
Ted Kelly, director and lead counsel specializing in clean energy at the Environmental Defense Fund, noted that the Trump administration has been issuing emergency orders as coal plants approach their scheduled retirements, with Stanton being next on the list. Kelly explained that one reason for the higher costs is that all the coal plants under these emergency orders are older than 20 years. "In general as plants get older they have more problems," he said. "Coal just is a costly resource."
In response to inquiries, OUC stated that its board would consider a proposed fuel rate decrease in December that could save customers about $5 monthly, or $3.3 million in total, if approved. The new rate would take effect in April 2027. A utility representative disputed the claims regarding operating costs, stating they were "based on assumptions that do not reflect the comprehensive analysis OUC regularly undergoes to balance reliability, affordability, and sustainability."
The utility further explained that its own analysis found that adding new solar and energy storage while enhancing fuel flexibility at Stanton Units 1 and 2 was a more cost-effective option than building new fossil-based generation resources or converting the units strictly to natural gas in the near term. OUC claimed this approach helps maintain affordable and reliable electric service while protecting customers from fuel market volatility, balancing affordability, reliability, sustainability, and resiliency while achieving CO2 reduction goals of 50% by 2030 and 75% by 2040.
The Environmental Defense Fund, Sierra Club, and Earthjustice filed the legal challenge in July on behalf of Florida Rising, a grassroots group representing communities of color. The groups argued that the order failed to demonstrate an actual emergency existed, exceeded the agency’s statutory authority, and violated the National Environmental Policy Act. They also contended that continuing to operate the coal plant would increase harmful air pollution for residents near the facility and lead to higher energy costs for Floridians, further burdening underserved communities vulnerable to climate impacts such as hotter temperatures, rising seas, and damaging storms.
The Trump administration faces similar legal challenges regarding emergency orders in other states. In Michigan, the administration issued a seventh consecutive emergency order on November 13 to extend operations at the J.H. Campbell Generating Plant. This occurred despite a U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit ruling in September that found no emergency warranted the order and that it exceeded the Department of Energy’s authority.
Marshall highlighted the impact of these costs on Florida residents, noting that the state already has some of the highest energy bills in the nation. "It’s just making things worse when we should be trying to make things better," he said.
U.Laurent--LCdB